critique, the evidence gate
critique audits co-write’s draft against the track’s own evidence
record and revises what the record does not support. It is a gate on the
artifact, not a fifth capability.
How it works:
- The audit is code. The model’s only job is to inventory the claims in the draft; deciding whether the record supports each one is not left to a model’s opinion of its own writing.
- Revision happens within a bound you set:
--critique-rounds, orZORP_CRITIQUE_ROUNDS, default 2. - The pass refuses to run if the evidence record moved under it. That is what keeps it from touching the Kill Threshold or anything else that was pre-registered.
- What it found is written into the record.
The design stance is the same one the whole system takes: detection is code, and the model only interprets. A model asked whether it likes its own draft will like its own draft.